The short answer
List the marketing jobs your offices need, then decide for each one whether your team, an agency, or both will do it. A common answer is a hybrid: a small group team that sets priorities and holds the accounts, and an agency for specialist work.
Give every shared job one lead who decides. Leave no job with nobody.
Whoever does the work, keep the Business Profiles, Ads accounts, Analytics, Tag Manager, Search Console, and domains in the group's name, with two group people on each.
Three ways to staff it
None of these is right for every group. The better question is which jobs each side should own, and who holds the accounts.
In-house
Your own marketing team
People on the group's payroll run the profiles, ads, site, and reports. They know the offices and the schedule. The risk is depth: one person often carries several skills, and work stops when they leave or go on leave.
Where it fits: Often fits a group with steady work, a few offices that look alike, and someone who can hire and manage marketers.
Agency
An outside team does the work
An agency brings people for ads, search, web, and reporting at once. The group buys the skills without hiring each one. The risk is distance: the agency may not know which office is short on hygiene time this month unless someone tells it.
Where it fits: Often fits a group that is adding offices fast or needs skills it cannot hire for one at a time.
Hybrid
A small group team plus an agency
One or two people at the group set priorities, hold the accounts, and handle office news and reviews. The agency handles the specialist work, such as ads builds, site changes, and tracking. The risk is gaps: jobs fall between the two sides unless each one has a lead.
Where it fits: Often fits a group of several offices that wants control of the accounts and the plan, with specialist help on call.
Groups often move between models. A group of three offices may start with an agency, then hire one marketer to hold the accounts and handle office news as it grows. A group that adds offices quickly may lean on an agency for launches. The playbook for groups of 3 to 10 offices covers what changes at each size.
The jobs to split
Split by job, not by channel. These are the usual jobs.
Business Profiles
Hours, holiday hours, photos, services, and new offices on each profile.
Review replies
Someone who knows the office reads and answers reviews, without patient details.
Google Ads
Campaign builds, budgets by office, search terms, and conversion setup.
Website and office pages
New office pages, provider changes, treatment pages, and redirects after a move.
Search Console and technical SEO
Indexing, errors, and site changes that affect search.
Analytics and tags
Tag Manager, Analytics events, and an office label on every lead.
Monthly report by office
Calls, forms, bookings, and spend for each office, in one sheet.
Calls and web form follow-up
The people who answer and book. Usually the offices or a central call team.
Jobs that need office knowledge, such as review replies, holiday hours, and new provider news, tend to sit well with the group. Jobs that need a specialist and change less often, such as tracking setup, ads builds, and site templates, tend to sit well with an agency.
Work split planner
Pick who does each job and who holds its account. The findings show gaps, shared jobs without a lead, and accounts to move into the group's name.
Accounts stay with the group
The model can change. The accounts should not have to. Each platform has a way to let a team or agency work without holding the account.
- Business Profiles. Owners can add and remove users and remove a profile. Managers can do almost everything else, including editing info and replying to reviews. A profile has one primary owner.
- Google Ads. Standard access edits campaigns. Only Admin access can give access, accept or unlink manager accounts, and add product links. A manager account can own office accounts, and the agency can link its own manager account.
- Google Analytics. Administrators manage users. Editors have full control of property settings but cannot manage users.
- Tag Manager. Google asks for at least two active administrators, and for the account to be managed by someone in your organization, not an external agency. Container access can be read, edit, approve, or publish.
- Search Console. For an SEO audit, Google suggests granting read access only.
The step-by-step moves are in Google Ads ownership for dental groups, Tag Manager for dental groups, Google Analytics 4 for dental groups, and domains and DNS for dental groups.
Questions before you hire
Ask the same questions of an agency and of a person you might hire. Several come from Google's own list for hiring an SEO.
- Can you show examples of previous work? Google's own list of questions to ask an SEO starts here, along with references from past clients.
- Will you share every change you make? Google suggests asking whether the provider will share all changes and the reasoning behind its advice.
- What results do you expect, and when? Ask how they measure success. Google's page says no one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google.
- What is your experience in dental and in our area? Google lists industry and country or city experience as questions worth asking.
- Who at the group holds each account? Ask how they will work inside accounts the group owns, at the access level the group grants.
- Who covers the work when someone is out? For an in-house hire or a small agency, ask who picks up each job during leave or after a resignation.
To compare agencies side by side, use the agency scorecard for dental groups. To test one on a few offices first, see pilot offices for an agency trial.
Making a hybrid work
A hybrid works when both sides know who decides. Keep a short written split: the job, the lead, the backup, and the account it runs on.
Every week
The group sends office news: new providers, closures, hours, and which offices have open time. The agency confirms what it changed.
Every month
One report by office, and a list of every change made to the site and the accounts, with the reason for each.
Every quarter
A group person reads the accounts directly, checks who has access, and removes people who left.
Google's Search Central page puts the stakes plainly: you are responsible for the actions of any companies you hire. A change list each month keeps that manageable. The office report format is in a marketing report for each office.
Red flags
The agency owns the accounts
If the Ads manager account, the profiles, or the Tag Manager account sit in the agency's name, leaving gets hard. Move them into the group's name first.
One person holds every login
Tag Manager's help warns that a sole administrator who changes roles can lock you out. Keep two group people on every account.
Write access for an audit
Google suggests giving an SEO read access to Search Console for an audit, not write access.
Ranking guarantees
Google's page is plain: no one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google.
Shared jobs with no lead
If both sides own review replies or office updates, each assumes the other did it. Name one lead per job.
Reports only from the doer
If the agency both runs the ads and writes the only report on them, someone at the group should read the account directly.
Checklist
Team checklist
0 of 12 done
Related guides
If the group is leaving one agency for another or for an in-house team, the handoff steps are in switching marketing agencies across a dental group. How to split shared and office costs is in shared and office marketing costs.
The map of the other group jobs is marketing a multi-location practice or DSO.
For a multi-office group
DDS Web Solutions builds websites and runs search, ads, and reporting for dental practices. Our team has been building websites since 2014, we have served 100+ practices, and our offices are in Sacramento and San Mateo.
For a group, we can work as the agency side of a hybrid: inside accounts the group owns, with a monthly change list and a report by office through SmileTrak. We do not promise a ranking or a number of new patients.
FAQ
Should a dental group build an in-house team or hire an agency?
It depends on how much steady work the offices create and whether the group can hire and manage marketers. A common answer is a hybrid: a small group team that holds the accounts and the plan, and an agency for specialist work. Whichever you choose, keep the accounts in the group's name.
Can a small group do its own SEO?
Often, yes. Google's Search Central page says a small local business can probably do much of the work itself, starting with Google's SEO starter guide. Knowing the basics also helps you spot advice that goes against Google's guidance.
What access should an agency get on our Business Profiles?
Manager access is usually enough. Google says managers can do almost everything an owner can, except add or remove users and remove the profile. Keep a group person as owner on every office profile.
What Google Ads access does an agency need?
Standard access lets a user edit campaigns. Admin access adds the power to give access, accept and unlink manager accounts, and add product links. One setup that keeps control: Admin for two group people, Standard for the agency's staff, or the agency's manager account linked to the group's without owner status.
Who should administer Tag Manager?
Google's Tag Manager help says to make sure the account is managed by someone in your organization, not an external agency, and to keep at least two active administrators. The agency can still have publish rights on the containers it works in.
Are we responsible for what an agency does on our site?
Google's Search Central page says you are responsible for the actions of any companies you hire. Ask the agency to explain each change it plans, and keep a list of what it changed.
Sources
- Google Search Central: Do you need an SEO?
- Google Business Profile Help: Manage your Business Profile owners and managers
- Google Ads Help: About access levels in your Google Ads account
- Google Ads Help: About Google Ads manager accounts
- Analytics Help: Access and data-restriction management
- Tag Manager Help: Managing users and permissions